Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Boston North News

Local news for the communities north of Boston

City Hall

Salem Council Refuses to Remove Historical Commission Member Who Exposed Short-Term Rental Gaps, Backs Peabody Essex Museum Union 10-0 and Hears Three Home Rule Ideas to Keep the Skipper Running

Milo Martinez told the council that only about one in three Salem short-term rentals has ever applied to register. The mayor's request to remove him from the Historical Commission drew two yes votes. A Charlotte Forten Park ordinance with $150 fines went to committee after councillors said it targets unhoused residents, and the Skipper's $400,000-a-year cost increase got three home rule petitions and a parking surcharge on the table.

This report was written from the public record of the meeting or event it covers.

Leer esta nota en español

Salem Council keeps Milo Martinez on the Historical Commission, backs the PEM union and weighs Skipper funding

The Salem City Council on Thursday, November 12, declined to remove Milo Martinez from the Historical Commission, with two councillors voting for Mayor Dominick Pangallo’s recommendation, five against and two answering present. The same meeting adopted a resolution supporting a union drive at the Peabody Essex Museum by a 10-0 roll call, sent a proposed Charlotte Forten Park ordinance to committee after an hour of debate about whom it is written for, denied a staff request to withdraw the rooftop wind energy ordinance, approved nine days of free holiday parking over one objection, and advanced the $1.2 million High Street Park renovation on three separate votes. Earlier in the evening the Administration and Finance Committee heard the transportation director lay out three home rule petitions and a parking surcharge that could pay for the Salem Skipper after its new contract adds about $400,000 a year.

Council President Alice Rose Merkl presided. Ward 1 Councillor Erin Turowski was not called in any roll call. This account comes from Salem Access Television’s live stream, which carried the 6 p.m. committee meeting and then lost audio for roughly 50 minutes, so the public testimony period, the Bridge Street utility pole hearing, the board appointments and the first of the mayor’s prior-year invoice orders are not on the recording. The agenda and our preview list what was scheduled.

Martinez: “entirely opt-in”

The removal order, brought under Section 61 of the city charter, was the first use of that power that anyone in the chamber could recall. Merkl announced that Councillor at Large Ty Hapworth had recused himself, and Ward 2 Councillor Andrew Smith, who moved the order as the agenda required, asked that Martinez be allowed to speak.

Martinez, who operates a short-term rental downtown, said he filed his original registration and certificate of fitness application on October 4, 2023, as application number STR245, and that when he reapplied in August 2026 his new application was numbered STR697. By his arithmetic, 452 applications over 36 months works out to about 154 a year, while listing websites estimate 400 to 500 short-term rentals operating in the city. “Roughly one in three units has submitted an application with the City,” he said, “and even then there’s no guarantee that every application leads to a certificate of fitness. It is plain to anyone who is looking that this registration process is entirely opt-in.” He said he paid his registration fee by September 22, passed inspection October 22 and received his certificate October 30, after he had told the council at its October 8 public testimony period that he had operated without one.

He said Airbnb remits the city’s occupancy tax on every booking whether or not a unit is registered, so the city collects more from an unregistered rental than from a long-term tenant, a point he called “a perverse incentive.” He said the solicitor’s removal letter reached him at 3:30 p.m. Monday, November 9, the agenda went out at 4:19 p.m. Tuesday, Wednesday was a holiday, and he did not have written confirmation that Thursday’s item was a hearing rather than a simple vote until late Thursday morning. “This process has been rushed unfairly,” he said, “and to the layperson’s eyes may be perceived as done so intentionally to prevent further discussion on this issue.”

Smith said the question in the mayor’s letter was whether Martinez violated his oath as a commissioner, and that renting a room on his own time “has nothing to do with the oath.” He added that a Microsoft outage had kept councillors from receiving email since 1 p.m., so they did not know the full extent of the public response. Merkl then called a three-minute recess so the solicitor could advise whether Martinez wanted a continuance to the December 3 meeting; after the recess, which ran closer to ten minutes, Martinez said he wanted to hear from every councillor and proceed.

Ward 6 Councillor Katelyn Holappa said the executive branch’s proper remedy was to enforce the short-term rental ordinance, not to invoke the charter. Ward 3 Councillor Jason Sydoriak disagreed, saying public testimony showed “three years of intentionally doing an experiment,” that board members serve at the pleasure of the mayor, and that “when you take an oath it is about public trust.” Councillor at Large Kyle Alexander Davis called removal “a wild overreaction,” noted that the ordinance already carries fines and revocation, and said he had himself smoked in a city park after dark in violation of an ordinance. Councillor at Large Conrad J. Prosniewski, who spent 11 years working in the courthouse, moved to send the matter to the Committee of the Whole because 36 hours was not due process; he withdrew the motion after Martinez said his statement would not change. Ward 5 Councillor Lydia C. King said the city has fines for this and often does not apply them, that she believes about two-thirds of Salem’s short-term rentals operate illegally, and that the removal “feels like an extra step of retaliation from the same departments that are supposed to be in charge of enforcing the ordinance.”

On the roll call, Ward 4 Councillor Timothy G. Flynn and Sydoriak voted yes; Davis, Holappa, King, Smith and Ward 7 Councillor Andrew W. Varela voted no; Prosniewski and Merkl answered present. Smith moved immediate reconsideration in the hope it would not prevail, and it did not.

Peabody Essex Museum: “Salem is a union town”

Smith’s resolution says that as of November 1 at least 66 percent of museum workers had signed cards to organize with the American Federation of Teachers, and it calls on management to recognize the union voluntarily rather than force an election. A group of museum employees stayed in the chamber past 9:30 p.m. for the vote. Smith said many of them hold master’s degrees in fine arts and “love where they work,” and asked the museum not to use delay tactics “that have been used in the past.” Sydoriak, who said he is a dues-paying union member, Flynn, who spent his career in Salem Firefighters Local 172, and Prosniewski, a union official for more than 35 years, each spoke in favor. Davis asked the workers to “put us to work” on a picket line if it comes to that, and King said “Salem is a union town and we love that.” The roll call was 10-0.

Skipper: three petitions, one surcharge

The 6 p.m. Administration and Finance Committee meeting, co-posted with the Committee of the Whole and chaired by Davis, took up the Skipper contract the council debated in September. Transportation Director Kucharski said the new contract with Via Transportation will cost about $400,000 more per year after its first nine months, and that a resident and non-resident fare study with Via suggests charging visitors about $5 instead of $2 would save only $24,000 to $25,000, because the data show most riders are local. He listed three home rule petitions: an additional 10 cents per ride on transportation network company trips, which would double the state’s current per-ride payment and bring in about $84,000 a year; a 5 percent motor vehicle excise surcharge, about $267,000; and a 0.4 percent share of state motor vehicle fuel tax collections, about $2.4 million. The parking options were a 50-cent hourly surcharge for non-residents in the roughly 370 Passport-app lot spaces, about $255,000, or 50 cents on every metered space downtown, about $580,000, with residents still exempt in the lots.

Pangallo said home rule petitions rarely pass, that the excise surcharge mirrors a provision the Legislature stripped from the Municipal Empowerment Act and sent to study, and that the fuel tax figure came from applying the city’s Chapter 90 formula to statewide collections because the tax is collected at wholesale. He said every proposal was chosen for its “nexus to transportation” so that drivers, not property taxpayers, fund the alternative, and that the goal is to stop relying on one-time grants: “We don’t want to be in a situation where the program is kind of on life support again.” Salem State University accounts for 13 to 15 percent of ridership but “has not had any indication that they are prepared to provide any funding,” he said; the city is instead asking to use the university’s and Salem Hospital’s chargers overnight for electric vehicles the new contract allows.

Answering Sydoriak, the city’s purchasing director said the contract was awarded through a Chapter 30B request for proposals in which Via “was among the more expensive options” but was rated highest on continuity of service. The fleet is capped at eight vehicles, so costs cannot run past the contract maximum, and if the city cannot fund the remaining years “it just ends” without penalty. Kucharski said utilization is about 4.5 trips per vehicle hour, which puts the city’s cost at $14 to $16 a ride; fares are $2, $1 for students and seniors, and $3 after 7 p.m. Top destinations are Salem High School, the Point, the MBTA station, Shetland Park, Hawthorne Square and Walmart. Holappa asked whether extending metered hours past 6 p.m. had been studied, and Kucharski said the mayor’s office is working on those numbers along with the enforcement cost. Flynn asked what the program’s purpose is; Pangallo said the original goal was fewer single-occupancy vehicles and a way for families to own one car instead of two. The presentation was received and filed on four hands, and the council later received and filed the committee report.

Charlotte Forten Park: “where they can be”

The mayor’s proposed Article V for Chapter 26 would bar 15 activities at the Derby Street park, including entering between sunset and sunrise except on the Harborwalk, setting up tables or tents, smoking, drinking, metal detecting and “disorderly conduct,” with fines of $150, $200 and $300. Hapworth moved it to the Committee on Government Services, co-posted with the Committee of the Whole, but said these measures are arriving “piecemeal” and that a task force including unhoused residents and public health officials should study them first. Davis said he would rather vote it down: “We cannot keep legislating where unhoused people cannot be and allow that list to get longer and longer and longer without answering the question of where they can be.” He said the council had deliberately struck fines from the no-camping ordinance because fining people in crisis “is cruel,” and that language was now back.

Holappa compared the text with the Salem Common ordinance and said the park’s fines are six times higher and the tent and table clause does not exist for the Common. Sydoriak asked whether the ordinance is “some sort of Trojan horse used to manage the homeless population.” Smith said the wrestling clause would ticket his three-year-old. King asked how the city is spending $1.3 million in opioid settlement money and why the housing roadmap’s stability section remains the least complete, and described Edinburgh’s and Peabody’s use of empty hotel rooms. Varela said all parks should be governed under Parks and Recreation rules; Hapworth answered that Charlotte Forten Park, like the Common, is public land rather than a Parks and Recreation park, which is why it needs its own rules. The referral passed on a voice vote.

High Street Park, free parking, outdoor dining

The council appropriated $163,099 in short-term capital funds for the High Street Park renovation, adopted a resolution authorizing the mayor to seek a state PARC grant of up to $425,000 toward the $1,246,576 project by the December 31 deadline, and gave first passage to an ordinance deleting the resident-only designation for the parking lot beside the High Street playground, because, Smith explained, grant rules forbid resident-only parking on park land. Davis said the project adds new play structures, a bocce court, rubber surfacing, shade trees and repairs to curbing and asphalt.

Free parking in city lots, garages and on-street spaces on November 27 through 29 and December 19 through 24 passed on a voice vote with Holappa opposed: “There’s no such thing as free parking.” Sydoriak asked the mayor’s office for data on whether the days actually draw shoppers. The “Peas for Fees” program, which waives up to $30 in late fees on a parking fine from November 27 to December 23 for two donated food items, passed without dissent. Prior-year invoices of $219.63 to Home Depot, $2,055 to the Massachusetts Tree Wardens and Foresters Association and $23,477.11 to EJ Prescott for water and sewer supplies each passed 10-0. The council accepted a $2,000 gift from Beverly-Peabody Lodge No. 1309 for Veterans Services and two oil paintings by Festus S. Rousseau, a former Salem High School art teacher, valued at $4,200 together, which will hang at the high school.

The mayor’s rewrite of the outdoor dining policy, which would route winter waiver requests through the Licensing Department before they reach the council, went to the Committee on Community and Economic Development, co-posted with the Committee of the Whole, on Hapworth’s motion. Varela said the change “is literally taking the authority from the City Council away,” and Davis said the current process, in which the council recently voted unanimously on a restaurant’s waiver, works. King said she would spend the weekend in a Northeast city with year-round outdoor dining and send photographs.

Wind, batteries and the rest

A recommendation from the directors of sustainability and planning that the council withdraw the rooftop wind energy zoning ordinance without prejudice ended with the council denying it. King first moved to send it to the Committee on Ordinances, Licenses and Legal Affairs, explaining that staff feared a conflict with the battery energy storage ordinance that hinged on the word “storage,” and that she had never intended to pass the wind ordinance Thursday. Varela moved to deny instead, saying the council “has the autonomy to figure out what we want to do with what we have in committee.” After a conference with the clerk over which motion took precedence, King withdrew hers and amended it to a denial, which carried on a voice vote; Merkl noted that a yes vote was a no. Holappa said staff had not engaged with the council on the ordinance as much as she wanted, drew a gentle point of order from Merkl about characterizing departments, and asked for stronger collaboration. The Planning Board’s favorable report on the wind ordinance then went to the same committee, and the battery storage ordinance went to the Planning Board for a joint public hearing.

Also Thursday: the council created an ad hoc committee of four councillors, Human Resources Director Lisa Cammarata and City Solicitor James Wellock, non-voting, to hire a permanent city clerk; received and filed Wellock’s opinion on the Seal the Ballot referendum petition and the group’s own petition; ordered a December 3 hearing on National Grid’s Everett Road conduit; granted street use for the Wicked Frosty Four on January 1, the Festivus 5K for Autism on December 13 and the Marblehead Half Marathon on April 11; referred 14 claims to committee; and gave second and final passage to the outdoor lighting ordinance and the Cleveland Street handicapped parking space. The Committee of the Whole’s rules review stays in committee. Merkl thanked Acting City Clerk Maureen Elizabeth Fisher and the elections staff for a 50 percent turnout election, and Flynn asked for a moment of silence for a 19-year-old Ward 4 resident who died November 6 after a long fight with muscular dystrophy and had served as a Muscular Dystrophy Association ambassador for the Salem and Gloucester fire departments.

The recording is on YouTube. The council next meets December 3.