The state Department of Elementary and Secondary Education has found that Peabody Public Schools followed its own promotion policy when it moved 22 eighth graders on to high school, the students whose lottery-won seats at Essex Tech were later rescinded on the ground that they should not have been promoted. The finding was first reported Thursday, November 12 by Patch, which quoted from the department’s conclusions.
“The district complied with its own promotion policy as it relates to the 22 promoted students,” the department concluded, according to Patch. The review came in response to a complaint filed by Essex Tech Superintendent Heidi Riccio. We have not obtained the department’s document itself; the quotations from it here are as Patch published them.
What the dispute is about
Essex Tech, the regional career and technical high school in Danvers, filled its 71 seats for Peabody students for the 2026-2027 school year through a blind lottery, the admissions system the state required after doing away with the earlier process of interviews, recommendations and reviews of attendance and interest. The school then rescinded the admission of 22 of those Peabody students, according to a statement Peabody Public Schools posted on October 14, which says it was done “without notice” and that Essex Tech said publicly the students “had failed Grade 8 and should not have been promoted.”
Essex Tech’s position, as Patch describes it, was that the students had not met eighth-grade requirements by Peabody’s own standards and so were not eligible for admission. Peabody’s policy lists failing two or more subjects as “grounds for automatic retention,” and Essex Tech argued that should have kept at least some of the 22 from moving up.
Peabody’s position was that the decision to promote belongs to the sending district, and that Essex Tech, as a public school, has to seat any student who wins a place in the lottery and whom the district has promoted.
What the state found
The department read the policy the district’s way. “The term ‘grounds’ is not uniquely or otherwise defined by the policy,” it wrote, according to Patch, and so the policy can reasonably be read “to allow, but does not require, the retention of a student who fails more than two core classes.”
The review also counted. Of the 22 students, seven failed more than two core classes, eight failed one or two, and seven did not fail any, Patch reported from the investigation. Fourteen of the 15 who failed at least one core class “took relevant remediation courses.” For every one of the 22, the department found, the district “conducted an individualized assessment of each student and their relevant circumstance before determining whether to promote or retain the student,” weighing engagement with remediation courses, attendance and “other factors unique to the student.”
The Patch report does not say what, if anything, the finding requires Essex Tech to do, whether any of the 22 students will now be offered the seats they drew, or where they are enrolled this fall. It does not include a response from Essex Tech to the finding.
What Peabody has said
The district’s October 14 statement, titled “A Message To Our Community,” is blunt. It calls the claim that the students failed eighth grade “flatly not true” and describes Essex Tech’s actions as “a startling departure from the norms of what is expected in public school districts” and “a serious breach in ethical standards expected from a public school.”
The statement lays out the district’s reasoning on promotion. Fewer than 2 percent of Peabody students are held back, it says, against about 1 percent statewide. A student who struggles in the first term and then passes with high marks in the next three “should not be denied educational opportunities at Essex Tech or at any other public school.” It cites research that holding students back in eighth grade can raise dropout rates later, and argues that a failed class may reflect attendance, a skill gap or immaturity and that a struggling student can be placed in a more suitable course level in ninth grade. The statement says “every rising ninth grade student in Peabody has a seat waiting for them.”
The same day, the district published a separate post on its credit recovery programs at Peabody Veterans Memorial High School: an afternoon Period 8 program, an online night school supported by three graduation coaches, and the Peabody Learning Academy. It cites state figures showing the high school’s four-year graduation rate rose from 85.7 percent in 2024 to 90.7 percent in 2025, above the state’s 90.2 percent target, and says the school has added a ninth-grade dean of students, two counselors assigned to that grade and 20 advisory teachers.
Twenty-one superintendents sign on
Peabody Superintendent Josh Vadala released a joint statement with 20 other North Shore superintendents, Patch reported, among them the superintendents of Beverly, Danvers, Marblehead, Salem and Swampscott. “It is our firm belief that when a Massachusetts public school district promotes a student to the next grade level, all other public school districts must respect and accept the decision,” it says, whether a family moves, a student uses school choice, or an eighth grader chooses a career and technical school.
The statement also regrets the fight itself, according to Patch, saying comprehensive districts and vocational schools have “a long history of collaboration” and that the infighting does no good, “least of all to the students caught in the crossfire.”
The larger argument over the lottery
The dispute follows the state’s switch to the lottery. Vocational school leaders, Riccio among them, argued that the old process helped match students to programs they were suited for, Patch notes. Superintendents of sending districts and some elected officials argued that it worked as a merit screen that shut out students who most needed a vocational path. The Peabody statement refers to a column by the Essex Tech superintendent and rejects what it calls the notion “that students should be cast aside and retained en masse.”



